Friday, December 27, 2013

Are you a listener or a solver? Are they mutually exclusive?

Rabbi Philip Weintraub
Congregation Agudas Israel
Parshat Vaera
12/28/2013

What does it mean to be listener or a leader?  When do they overlap and when are they different categories? In our parsha, Va’era, we hear about the dynamics of Gd, Moses, Aaron and later on, Pharaoh.  

In this parsha (and others), we find Moshe as a reluctant leader.  He feels that he does not have the necessary skills.  He is not a comfortable speaker.  He fears people will not listen to him or will not respect him.  He goes to his mentor, GD, with these concerns and GD does not seem to respond.

י  וַיְדַבֵּר ה", אֶל-מֹשֶׁה לֵּאמֹר.
10 And the LORD spoke unto Moses, saying:
יא  בֹּא דַבֵּר, אֶל-פַּרְעֹה מֶלֶךְ מִצְרָיִם; וִישַׁלַּח אֶת-בְּנֵי-יִשְׂרָאֵל, מֵאַרְצוֹ.
11 'Go in, speak unto Pharaoh king of Egypt, that he let the children of Israel go out of his land.'
יב  וַיְדַבֵּר מֹשֶׁה, לִפְנֵי ה" לֵאמֹר:  הֵן בְּנֵי-יִשְׂרָאֵל, לֹא-שָׁמְעוּ אֵלַי, וְאֵיךְ יִשְׁמָעֵנִי פַרְעֹה, וַאֲנִי עֲרַל שְׂפָתָיִם.  {פ}
12 And Moses spoke before the LORD, saying: 'Behold, the children of Israel have not hearkened unto me; how then shall Pharaoh hear me, who am of uncircumcised lips?' {P}
יג  וַיְדַבֵּר ה", אֶל-מֹשֶׁה וְאֶל-אַהֲרֹן, וַיְצַוֵּם אֶל-בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל, וְאֶל-פַּרְעֹה מֶלֶךְ מִצְרָיִם--לְהוֹצִיא אֶת-בְּנֵי-יִשְׂרָאֵל, מֵאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם.  {ס}
13 And the LORD spoke unto Moses and unto Aaron, and gave them a charge unto the children of Israel, and unto Pharaoh king of Egypt, to bring the children of Israel out of the land of Egypt. {S}
GD seems to ignore Moses’ concern.  Yet, he now begins to speak to Aaron, as well.  In effect, Gd appoints Aaron as Moses’ spokesperson, and then continues as if nothing happened!  The rest of the chapter details genealogies and it is not until chapter 7 that we hear more about this appointment.  There we hear:
א  וַיֹּאמֶר ה" אֶל-מֹשֶׁה, רְאֵה נְתַתִּיךָ אֱלֹהִים לְפַרְעֹה; וְאַהֲרֹן אָחִיךָ, יִהְיֶה נְבִיאֶךָ.
1 And the LORD said unto Moses: 'See, I have set thee in God's stead to Pharaoh; and Aaron thy brother shall be thy prophet.
ב  אַתָּה תְדַבֵּר, אֵת כָּל-אֲשֶׁר אֲצַוֶּךָּ; וְאַהֲרֹן אָחִיךָ יְדַבֵּר אֶל-פַּרְעֹה, וְשִׁלַּח אֶת-בְּנֵי-יִשְׂרָאֵל מֵאַרְצוֹ.
2 Thou shalt speak all that I command thee; and Aaron thy brother shall speak unto Pharaoh, that he let the children of Israel go out of his land.
ג  וַאֲנִי אַקְשֶׁה, אֶת-לֵב פַּרְעֹה; וְהִרְבֵּיתִי אֶת-אֹתֹתַי וְאֶת-מוֹפְתַי, בְּאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם.
3 And I will harden Pharaoh's heart, and multiply My signs and My wonders in the land of Egypt.
So on the one hand, Gd was a clear leader.  Gd heard Moses’ concern and immediately addressed it.  Gd solved the problem, forcing Moses to confront his issues and move on.

I wonder how this method of mentoring would work in the modern day.  If I were to go to one of my rabbinic colleagues/mentors, I would hope they would address my concerns, rather than just fixing them.  Yet, Gd does exactly that.  

When we hear a problem are we supposed to fix it or listen and allow the person to make their own plan?

Regarding this issue we sometimes speak about gender dynamics.  Whether true or not, some say that “women listen” and “men fix.”  I am sure we could find dozens of examples where this is absolutely true or absolutely false, but I think that ideally, listening and fixing are two very important tools in our interpersonal toolbox.

As most of you know, one of the ways I continue my rabbinic education is through clinical-pastoral education, CPE.  CPE is a program that focuses on listening.  We are to be non-judgmental, calming presences.  The focus is on hearing people where they are.  It is not about doing nothing, but about helping the person feel their feelings, recognize their situation and decide what they need to do.  Rather than giving a person the “answer”, the focus is on helping them discover their choices for themselves.  Being present and allowing them to consider their own feelings or choices can be very powerful, especially when one is present with people who rarely get to consider their own actions or feelings.

On the other hand, there are many cases when giving a solution is quite helpful.  In the military, it is much better for soldiers to follow orders than to write their own.  In an operating room, the surgeon tells those around her what they need to do.  In one’s own home, sometimes it is better for a parent to say “this is what we are having for dinner.”

At the same time, Rashi, our friendly medieval rabbi and commentator, writes that the midrash emphasizes that Pharaoh must be spoken to with respect to his position.  Even as Gd commands them to tell Pharaoh “let my people go”, he reminds them that they must respect the dignity due to his office.  (This is a lesson many in politics should remember!)  Yet, it is not just for those in positions of power.  When we talk to others, whether we are listening or trying to solve their problems, we must show them the appropriate respect.  I think this says a lot about the Jewish tradition that even as Gd helped the Jewish people leave Egypt, with all of the signs and wonders, we were still concerned about Pharaoh’s feelings and public image!

I read an article recently about parenting.  It was about how a father interacted with his children.  As they were growing up, he would regularly advise them how to deal with different situations.  After awhile, he realized he was missing out.  He was not giving them the space to discover their own solutions.  One day he decided to try just listening.  He found out that his children had gained great problem-solving skills in spite of him.  When given the opportunity, they could find their own way to reason.  He also discovered that sometimes a problem did not need to be solved at all.  Sometimes his children just wanted him to empathize, to acknowledge that teenage life (like all life) isn’t always fair, that friends can be mean and frustrating.

In the Jewish tradition, shalom bayit, peace in the home is a very important value.  It is so important that Gd told a lie of omission to Abraham to preserve his peace with Sarah!  In the interests of shalom bayit, sometimes it can be helpful for partners to think about what kind of conversation they are having.  Do they want their spouse to ONLY listen and empathize OR do they want suggestions OR somewhere in between?  

Gd and Moses in THIS place in Torah offer us one model, but it is NOT the only one.


Questions to ponder:
Are there sources in the Torah that demonstrate empathetic listening?
How do we decide what model to use in any given situation.

Friday, November 1, 2013

Relational Judaism?


Rabbi Philip Weintraub
Congregation Agudas Israel
Parshat Toldot
November 2, 2013

This week we are reading Parshat Toldot.  We tell the story of Isaac and Rebecca, of Rebecca’s prophecy, the birth of Jacob and Esau, the convoluted blessings of Jacob and Esau and Rebecca’s driving role throughout the parsha.  What we have in this parsha, is the motivations, the drive, the influences of our biblical characters, what makes them tick.  In life, we can consider these same factors in how we treat each other, how we listen to each other, how we hear each others stories.  For many Jews, the Torah is a book of laws, of instruction.  While I certainly believe that is true, I think that the narratives, the stories are really what inspire us.

In Rashi’s commentary on the beginning of the Torah, the first verses of Genesis, he writes:
[Rashi] "In the beginning..." Rabbi Yitzhak said: The Torah should not have begun until "This month shall be for you [the first of the months]" (Exodus 12:1) which is the first mitzvah (commandment) which the Jewish people were commanded.
Here Rashi quotes one understanding of Torah, that it is a book of laws.  Yet he then continues:
[RASHI] Then for what reason does it begin with "In the beginning..."? Because of "He told His people the power of His works, to give them the inheritance of nations" (Psalm 111:6) That is, if the nations of the world say to the Jewish people, "You are robbers, because you conquered the lands of the seven [Canaanite] nations", they can answer them: "The whole world belongs to God, who created it and gave it to whomever it appeared right to Him. It was His will to give it to them and it was His will to take it from them and give it to us."
By sharing the story, the narrative, we claim ownership not only of Israel, defending our claim against the other nations, but we also claim ownership of our story.  We show our connection not only to the land, but to ourselves, to our heritage, to our peoplehood.

In the 11th century, Rabbi Yitzhak (Isaac) Alfasi, commonly known as the RIF, changed our understanding of the Talmud.  By cutting out much of the debate and leaving only the conclusions, he presented a preliminary code of Jewish law, a severely edited version of the Talmud.  For centuries it has been used to help determine Jewish law.  Yet a few centuries later, Jacob ben Solomon ibn Habib did the exact opposite, he created a version of the Talmud with only the midrashim, the stories, the narratives.  Exiled from Spain, he published his great work in Thessalonika.  Recognizing that the exiled Jews needed not only the laws, but the stories that inspire us, the narratives that help us see the holiness of our lives and our Torah.  (One of my teachers, Marjorie Lehman has published a phenomenal book about his motivations and writings, while an academic book, I think we could have a great discussion about it one day!)

This past Monday and Tuesday I spent at JTS, studying with the Rabbinical Assembly and JOIN-the Jewish Organizing Institute and Network.  The conference was called “Clergy 2.0: Leading Through Relationship.”  It accords with a book I just picked up and much of the recent research on strong and effective Jewish communities.  What the research tells us is that for us to be successful, we cannot just ask people the same questions and do all the same things.  We have to be part of our greater Jewish community, our national USCJ community, but we also have to be uniquely Newburghian.  We have to use our local talents and stories.  We have to really know each other as human beings and be a relational community.  Now, many of us have had many, many conversations with each other over the years.  Yet, with all of that, we can find that we have “known” each other for years, and do not truly know each other.  We know the surface, the names, the places, but not what motivates and drives us.

In the coming months, I would like to reflect on the lessons I learned at this conference.  I would like us to have the opportunities to share our stories in different ways.  I want to know what drives you?  What do you enjoy?  What inspires you?  What aspects of our congregation push you to be better?  How does prayer or spirituality drive your life?  Where do you find GD?  By asking and answering questions like this, we can greatly improve our interactions with each other, within our congregation and help us truly be a relational community.

As an example, I will share one story from my week.  My wife and I have similar computers and our chargers work interchangeably. My computer’s charger died.  I ordered a new one.  Wanting to play around and see if I could fix it, I did not immediately throw out the broken one.  My wife seeing two cords downstairs tosses one.  Unfortunately she threw away the working one.  At first I was really annoyed.  I just spent good money on a new charger and she threw the old (but working one away), leaving upstairs the dead one!  The next morning though, I laughed.  My grandparents would have found it pretty hilarious.  Why?  My grandmother, is a pack rat.  If she could keep anything, she will.  My grandfather was a tinkerer, he would fix things and resell them, but he also hated clutter and junk.  He would regularly toss things from the house, causing my grandmother stress--but keeping their apartment in good order.  When he passed away, that check was gone and her apartment became very, very cluttered.  For me, seeing their relationship parallel to my own made me consider my own tendencies to keep more than I need!  It makes me even more grateful to have my wife in my life, who can help keep me from saving every interesting article I ever find or every thing I have ever written!

In just a brief story like that, you can see that family is important to me, that I am proud to stand in the footsteps of those that came before me, but that I am also aware of the less positive traits I have and that I have inherited.  By being self-aware, I can hopefully work on my behavior so that I do not NEED Rebecca to toss my junk for me!

In a shul setting, we could talk about what brought you or me to your Jewish heritage.  Are you here because of your parents’ or grandparents’ inspiration? Did you have a moment in life where you felt the presence of GD and wanted to keep that feeling?  Do you love the melodies of the service?  Are they a comfort for you?  Does the beauty of our sanctuary help you find peace in the crazy world in which we live?  Do I inspire you through my words?

For me, I think back to a moment in Valdosta, GA.  While I can talk more about it another time, on one foot, as a 17-year-old, I subbed for the rabbi, who had known me for all of two weeks, but saw that I had the ritual skills to cover.  Standing on that bimah, I found my home, and have worked to find myself there since then.  He took a chance on me, recognizing that this young whippersnapper might be able to share a few words of Torah and lead the services.  That is one reason I am proud to stand before you today.

What are your stories?  What drives you?  To answer those questions, I would like to continue the listening campaign I began when I arrived.  Yet, I want to change how I listen, the questions I ask and better discover you and your interests.  I want to partner with you in getting to know our community on a deeper level.  I want us to consider our future and make CAI the best community it can be.  I want to thank you for all that you do and hope that our years together will lead to better relationships for all here at CAI.  

Shabbat Shalom!


Friday, October 25, 2013

Are we all sinners?

Rabbi Philip Weintraub
Congregation Agudas Israel

Sometimes I feel that there are so many details in Jewish law that it is impossible to follow them all. Nobody can. So everybody fails at something (at least) sometime. Are we then all "sinners"? How can we live with constant failure?
Below is my answer. At the link are three other rabbinic perspectives!

In many ways, I think this is one of the classic questions of life, law and Judaism.  How can we live with constant failure?

I think the classic answer is another question: is the glass half full or half empty?  Do we look at this as constant failure or constant success?  

The ritual mitzvot are essential to our lives.  Keeping kosher, observing Shabbat and festivals, praying regularly bring great meaning to our souls.  They structure our lives and help us find balance in a world always leading towards excess.  They teach us that we are most happy when we are happy with what we have, but also remind us that there is always more we can strive for--not just materially but spiritually.  Many of these mitzvot we might classify as bein adam l’Makom, between a person and GD.

Yet there is another entire section of mitzvot--those bein adam l’chavero, between an individual and his friend.  This includes vast sections of Jewish law--business ethics, familial ethics, sexual ethics, and more general interpersonal relationships.  Jewish law teaches us that we must be honest in our business dealings (that we are forbidden to have two sets of weights and measures--or two sets of books).  We are commanded to love our neighbors and not to stand idly by if they are in danger.  Jews are to treat one another with respect.  In all of these departments, we probably fulfill many mitzvot we never even knew were mitzvot!  

Whenever someone introduces him or herself to a rabbi, the introduction often continues, “but I’m not religious.”  I’ve heard this from doctors and garbage collectors, lawyers and airline ticket agents.  Yet, many people picked careers that match their Jewish values.  Reproductive specialists help couples fill the command to “be fruitful and multiply.”  Lawyers are advocates for the poor and those that need help.  Garbage collectors remove that which is disgusting from our homes, allowing us to pray and eat in places that do not smell terribly.

To be technical, we do all sin at times, but we also do many, many more mitzvot.  In the Aseret Hadibrot, the Ten Commandments, it says that Gd visits iniquity to the third and fourth generation of those that hate GD, but shows mercy for a thousand generations to those that love GD and keep the commandments.  In GD’s great mercy, we are given opportunity to atone--every day and on Yom Kippur.  We acknowledge our shortcomings, reminding GD that we are imperfect and must be judged on the scale of the imperfect.  

I want to end with two Hassidic tales:
A chassid once asked his rebbe, "why should wepray on Yom Kippur, after all, we will inevitably sin again." In response, the rebbe asked him to look out the window behind him. Outside there was a toddler who was just learning to walk. "What do you see?" asked the rebbe. The disciple replied, "I see a child, standing and falling," Day after day the chassid returned to witness the same scene. At the week’s end, the child stood and did not fall. The child’s eyes expressed the achievement of having attained the impossible. "So with us," said the rebbe. "We may fail again and again, but in the end, a loving God gives us the opportunities we need to succeed."

Another classic story. Reb Zusha was on his death bed, and he had tears streaming down his face. "Why are you crying?" asked his disciples. "If God asks me why I was not like Moses or Maimonides," answered Reb Zusha, "I will say, I was not blessed with that kind of leadership ability and wisdom." But I am afraid of another question," continued Reb Zusha, "what if God asks, Reb Zusha, why weren’t you like Reb Zusha? Why did you not find your inner being and realize your inner potential? Why didn’t you find yourself? That is why I am crying!"

Of the 613 mitzvot, many require the Temple, the ability to offer sacrifices.  For those, we have alternate paths, we remember the Temple, we recite the sacrifices.  Yet there are other mitzvot that we can fulfill.  We must continue to try to fulfill all the ones we can.  We must continue to try to be the best people we can be.  We must treat each other with love and respect.  We must remember that we will fail, but like the toddler, we must get up again and keep trying.  Tomorrow is another day and another opportunity!  The glass is half full.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Parshat Lech Lecha and the Jews 2013

Rabbi Philip Weintraub
Congregation Agudas Israel
Parshat Lech Lecha
10/12/13


Last year at this time Rebecca and I stood before you to celebrate the birth of our daughter. We spoke of the family and Jewish history of the name we chose, using this parsha Lech Lecha, to discuss the power of names.  In our parsha this morning, we find Avram and Sarai becoming Avraham and Sarah, cementing their Jewish identity through the power of a name change.  In our tradition, names have great meaning.  It is said that when a child is named, the parents have a prophetic moment, knowing that their choice will be a representation of their child.  Sometimes this prophecy does not work.  Some people simply do not match their names--and sometimes people change their names to match their true selves.
Naming and identity go hand in hand.  Even the pronunciation of the same name can have different meanings.  Using variations of Avraham, we can see this concept.  If you name your child Avi, you probably are an observant Jew, but not ultra-Orthodox.  If your child is Avruhum, you might be more frum. If your son is Abe, he might be old English or American--the same with Abraham.  
In the last two weeks, there has been a lot of tsurris about the Pew Foundation’s survey of American Jews.  High intermarriage, Jews that are proud of being Jewish but claim no religion, dropping affiliation, and the decline of Reform and Conservative Judaism are all causing stress among rabbis, cantors, educators and other Jewish leaders.  Writers are bemoaning these numbers and in the popular vernacular: generally freaking out.
At the same time, I have seen many articles looking at the numbers through rose-colored glasses.  They note that at no time in history could Jews be this proud of being Jewish, be so open in schools, work, life that they were Jewish and face as little discrimination and anti-Semitism, as Jews in America face.  Some even argue that assimilation is great and that our relatives fresh off the boat would be happy that their children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren can just be Americans without the Jewish part.
Like most Conservative rabbis, I tend to take a middle-ground on issues.  I am happy to hear that many Jews feel strongly about their Jewish identity, but I think that living a Jewish life strengthens Jewish identity even more than some undefinable Jewish culture.  As Mordechai Kaplan wrote, Judaism is a Civilization.  It is the art, the music, the langage, the land, the people, the writings, the history, the practices.  It is everything that Jews do.  Yet, for that to translate as an inheritance, as a yerusha, it needs a makor, a source.  In my mind, Gd, Israel and the Jewish people together form the core, the essence of Judaism.  To live fully as Jews, we must interact and have a relationship with all of these facets.  This is the lesson I teach over and over again.  This is what brings meaning to our lives and to our families.
Reading the articles about current demographics, it seems like many wonder about the chicken and the egg.  Are Jews less interested in Judaism because they intermarry or do they intermarry because they are not interested in Judaism?  On one foot I do not have a simple answer to this question.  When I look at Jewish history I see that in many societies, whether due to prejudice or anti-Semitism, it was simply impossible for Jews to intermarry.  There were always Jews that left the fold.  (One of the surprising statistics to many liberal Jews was that approximately half of Jews raised Orthodox either are now more liberal Jews or do not identify as Jewish.  Meaning that assimilation is a challenge not just for liberal Jews, but for Orthodox ones, as well.)  In the past, if someone was no observant, they were out of the community.  If someone married outside the faith, their relatives sat shiva.  Today we have discovered that someone can have a strong Jewish identity and have non-Jewish spouses or parents.  Someone can work on Shabbat, yet say Kiddush before going to the office!  (The funny thing about the last example is that 100 years ago, that was pretty common.  Synagogues had early minyanim on Saturday and Holidays not because people wanted davening at 7 and cholent by 10, but because people were going to their stores!
For some these recent studies are cause to mourn.  Without putting on rose colored glasses, I think we are at a crossroads of Jewish history.  We can continue as we always have, and we will be fine--to a certain extent.  Or we can ask more questions.  We can consider what is working in our communities and what is not.  I have mentioned before that just because a program or event worked in the past, does not mean it will work now and just because something failed previously, does not mean it will fail now.  
Time, technology, life change faster now than ever before.  As I look to the future of Judaism, the Jewish life I pray my daughter will have, I think the possibilities are endless.  Within the Conservative umbrella, there are new learning opportunities, independent minyanim and communities that did not exist a decade ago.  There are Jews across denominations who are bridging traditions and modernity in ways our ancestors could not have dreamed.  Do they all fit into traditional definitions of Jewish law?  No, but even within the four amot of halacha, there has been much innovation.  Questions of life and death through the power of medical technology, organ donation, fertility treatments have all expanded our understanding of Jewish law.  Science and technology have not only made observing Shabbat more complicated but help us understand the Divine in new ways.
At the end of the day, Judaism--especially in a place like Newburgh--, helps us with something sorely lacking in American society today--community.  Whether in politics, community service organizations, fraternal organizations, have seen a significant drop in interest.  Many today seem to care more about themselves than others.  We see politicians who care only about being re-elected.  They ignore their responsibilities, their (and our) obligations to the less fortunate.  We see Masons and Elks and bowling teams with fewer and fewer people.  We see churches around the country with fewer and fewer people in their pews.  What we need today, more than ever, is community.  This is what I see here.  This is what I hope my daughter will have.  We see people looking out for one another, helping one another with meals during shiva, assisting after the birth of a child.  I see friends helping friends.  I see families helping families.  I see a reminder that we are not alone.  Gd is with us AND Gd’s representatives are with us.  To the ones we assist, we are angels.  When we assist others we are GD’s presence, we are the image of GD.  Let us not forget that!              
 My undergraduate thesis advisor, Jonathan Sarna, closed his powerful book (and an adult education offering for the spring): American Judaism with the words of Simon Rawidowicz, who in a few short lines bared the souls of generations of Jews, writing:
                   
A nation dying for thousands of years. . .means a living nation. Our incessant dying means uninterrupted living, rising, standing up, beginning anew. . .If we are the last—let us be the last as our fathers and forefathers were. Let us prepare the ground for the last Jews who will come after us, and for the last Jews who will rise after them, and so on until the end of days.           
When I read those words almost ten years ago, I was immediately struck by their truth. So often Jewish history and the fear of the future becomes the lachrymose conception of Jewish history; they tried to kill us; we won; let’s eat. As the Passover Haggadah reminds us, an enemy has risen against us in every generation, yet we have prevailed. In addition to the threats from without, every generation has been withered by assimilation— whether it was Assyrian or other pagan religions, Hellenism, Zorastrianism, Christianity, Islam, modern secularism; all have siphoned off some of the best and worst of every Jewish generation. And yet, we continue.
And yet we thrive.
Dr. Sarna signed my copy, writing “In the hope that you will write fresh chapters in this history.”  My prayer is not that these words come true for me, but they come true for all of us and for our children.  Our heritage, our Judaism, our life is rich and a blessing to the world.  May our Jewish names and identities always be with us and may our lives be shaped by the Divine Will to do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with Gd. Amen.

Sources include:

 

 (After Shabbat I found this article and was inspired and interested by it: http://forward.com/articles/185461/pew-survey-about-jewish-america-got-it-all-wrong/)               

           

       


Wednesday, September 18, 2013

Chag Sukkot Sameach!

May this holiday bring you great joy.

I have been a big fan of Koren Publishers since I davened from their Hebrew only Chumash/Siddur in Israel. Their Tikkun for Torah readers is one of the most accurate out there.  Now they have done it again with their Talmud.  I have been doing Daf Yomi with Artscroll's iPad app and Koren's translation of Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz's fabulous Talmud.  Rabbi Steinsaltz is phenomenal and helped me (and many others) through his "easy" Hebrew translation of the Talmud.  The other major innovation of the Hebrew edition is that he added punctuation to the Talmud and Rashi.  (That doesn't sound like a big deal, but it is HUGE!)  Koren's English translation of his work adds color photos that have been a major help in understanding certain sections.  Sometimes it is just easier to see a picture than to understand a long complicated discussion.

http://www.korenpub.com/pdf/SukkotSample.pdf
While Sukkot won't be published for a while longer, in honor of Sukkot, Koren has sent out the sample above.  I will be using a piece of it in my Sukkot teaching this holiday.


Koren Publications was kind enough to send me a review copy of the following book.  While I will write more about it another time, I can say that it clearly and concisely explained the legal dimensions of a Sukkah (both minimum and maximum) helping me to ensure that my shul's Sukkah was kosher!

http://www.korenpub.com/EN/products/maggid/maggid/9781592643523

Hilkhot Mo'adim

Understanding the Laws of the Festivals


(All trademarks belong to their respective owners.)  I was not financially compensated for this post, although I did receive the email link above and the book mentioned.

Friday, September 13, 2013

Yom Kippur Yizkor--Seven Gates to let Gd in

Rabbi Philip Weintraub
Congregation Agudas Israel
Yom Kippur
September 14, 2013

L’shanah Tovah.  Just a moment ago you did a great mitzvah.  You showed that you are a part of this community and that you want to support it. Before I begin my formal address this morning, a comedic insert courtesy of Rabbi Kramer and Ken Copans.

May your hair, your teeth, your face-lift, your abs, and your stocks not fall. And may your blood pressure, your triglycerides, your cholesterol, your white blood count, your PSA and your mortgage interest not rise.
May you get a clean bill of health from your dentist, your cardiologist, gastroenterologist, urologist, nephrologist, proctologist, podiatrist, dermatologist, obstetrician, oncologist, rheumatologist, endocrinologist,ophthalmologist, ENT, psychiatrist, plumber, and the Internal Revenue.
May your work be secure, looking for work stress-free, good friends and contacts willing to make solid introductions.
May your checkbook / budget balance and include generous amounts for charity.
May you find a way to travel from anywhere to anywhere during rush hour in less than an hour, and when you get there may you find a parking space.
May what you see in the mirror delight you and what others see in you delight them.
May the telemarketers wait to make their sales calls until you finish dinner.
May Israel be safe, continue to flourish and strong against all enemies that plan to do harm.
May this Rosh Hashana, find you seated around the dinner table, together with your beloved family and cherished friends, ushering in the Jewish New Year ahead.
May you remember to say "I love you" at least once a day to your partner, your child, and your parent(s). You can say it to your secretary, your nurse, your butcher, your photographer, your masseuse, your seamstress, your hairdresser or your gym instructor, but not with a "twinkle" in your eye.
May we live as intended, in a world at peace with the awareness of the beauty in every sunset, every flower's unfolding petals, every baby's smile and every wonderful, astonishing, miraculous part of ourselves. Bless you with every happiness, great health, peace, tranquility, contentment and much love during the next year and all those that follow.
LeShanah Tovah U’metukah Tikatayvu Vetaychataymu.

Best sermon ever, right?   In truth, greatness can come out of tragedy.  Brilliance can come from dark places.  Some of our greatest poets, authors, scientists and teachers have struggled with depression and other forms of mental illness.  In the depths of our suffering we can find insight.  The Talmud teaches that suffering can be a gift from Gd, a time to reflect and consider our actions.  Yet at the same time, suffering can be unwanted and we may not desire the lessons we learned.  In one of my favorite passages of Talmud from Tractate Brachot, we discover that the rabbis did not enjoy suffering, saying that they wanted neither the suffering nor the reward.  In their illness though, they found inspiration in each other, in their community and in the power of a pastoral visit.  For me, this has been a personal inspiration.  Chaplaincy has been a way for me to meet people and bring holiness to their lives, to be a bright spot in the darkness.  The sugya, the narrative unit, of Brachot 5b tells us that visiting a person who is ill removes 1/60th of their suffering.  It asks why the miracle-working rabbis cannot heal themselves and concludes that a “prisoner cannot free himself from prison”--that we must help each other in our most difficult times.  This is the power of Jewish mourning customs.  Shiva, Shloshim, and Yahrzeit teach us that mourning is not only an individual journey, but a communal one.

It is amazing to me how a single moment can change and inspire us.  When I was in rabbinical school, a fellow student, Rafi Lehmann, passed away.  He was not my best friend.  He was an acquaintance.  I had met Rafi before rabbinical school, when his father Rabbi Allan Lehmann was the Jewish Chaplain at Brandeis.  Rafi loved Torah.  He loved the teachings of early Hasidic masters.  He loved good food, good meals and good friends.  Tragically he died shortly before he was scheduled to be married, a few months before he was to be ordained.  JTS arranged bus transportation to his funeral and many of us attended.  

At his funeral I had two transformative moments.  The second was at his burial, where they literally ran out of dirt.  There were still dozens of people in line to put a shovelful of dirt on his grave, but the grave was filled.  There was no more dirt.  Friends, family, acquaintances, students, teachers all came together and literally buried the one they had loved and learned from.  It was an inspiration to me of what we are supposed to do at Jewish funerals.

I told you the second, but not the first.  The first was at the synagogue.  Temple Emmanuel in Newton, a large Conservative synagogue, had large posters hanging throughout the building.  At every seat there was a booklet.  The title of the booklet was “Seven Gates.”  The gates were “Torah, Prayer, Israel, Shabbat, Redeeming the World, Building Community, and Teaching Jewish Values.”  Their website includes the same gates.  In that brochure, in these themes, they show that all are welcome and that all have a place.
“The Seven Gates stand for the proposition that everyone can find a place at Temple Emanuel. Whatever your passion, whatever inspires you, it is here. All you have to do is enter.
While these are entry points, it is not only about entering.
It is also about what you do once you are here. It is about engaging.
It is about finding meaning, purpose, and friends within a community of people who are moved by what moves you.
The gates are open and waiting for you.
Through which gate will you enter?”

The Seven Gates show that we are individuals and that together we make up a community.  The Seven Gates teach us that as individuals, we have different interests and access points.

I listed the seven gates, but what do they mean for us here?

Torah sounds self-evident, studying Torah, living Torah, teaching Torah, learning Torah.  But what is Torah?  Yes, it is the scroll we read from this morning, with Genesis-Deuteronomy, but Torah is also the entire canon of Jewish learning, as well as philosophy, science, and more.  Studying Torah can mean looking at our roots, our genealogy, which we can do together in a few weeks.  It can mean learning Hebrew, helping to make our texts and traditions more accessible.    If you have never learned to read Torah, I will be starting my third group of Read Hebrew America in October.  If you want to learn how to read Torah or Haftorah, join my other Thursday class, which focuses on liturgy and prayer skills.  Torah can also be learning about our Jewish traditions or even reading a good book.  If there is something that we are not doing yet, just ask!  I have been studying Daf Yomi, which can be an arduous path through Talmud.  the Conservative Yeshiva is beginning a Daf Shevui, studying a page of Talmud a week, which will be sent by email in Hebrew and English to you every day--a much more manageable task.  If you would like to discuss this project, please be in touch with me.  Torah is not just classes though, it is also our collective wisdom.  Every single person in this room has Torah to teach.  What I would love to see in the coming years is for YOU to teach ME (and everyone else).  If you are a talented dancer, musician, amateur historian, professional psychologist, doctor, lawyer, you have skills and knowledge that we do not all share.  Please teach us!

The second gate is Prayer.  We meet regularly for Tefillah, for Shabbat and Festivals.  We meet monthly before the Board Meeting for evening minyan--which lasts all of 8-15 minutes.  When congregants request a Yahrzeit or Shiva minyan, we make it happen.  Most of our prayer is traditional, but I open to trying different options.  Together we can connect our souls to the Divine!  

Israel is not just a vacation spot or a historical entity, but a living, breathing, Holy Place.  Visiting Israel is transformative, as some of our congregants discovered this summer with me.  Walking in the footsteps of our ancestors, we learned much about our history and I believe, much about ourselves.  It was a blessing to travel together and I hope that in another two or three years we can again travel to Israel as a community, uniting past and present in our souls.  Israel needs our attention from here, as well.  There are many people around the world who see Israel as a source of hate or violence.  They speak ill of Israel and often preach hate and violence against all Jews.  We must be advocates for Israel, reminding the world that Israel is valuable, important and rarely reflects the image that hate-mongerers and average people imagine.  Modern Israel is a young country.  It is growing and changing and we must be a part of that.  We have to show Israeli society that it is possible to be modern, Jewish, observant, egalitarian and open to all.  The Kotel should not be an ultra-Orthodox synagogue, but a place where ALL can daven.  The Temple Mount should be regularly accessible to Jews AND they should be allowed to pray there.  Israel should not be one of the only places in the world where I, a Conservative Rabbi, cannot perform a wedding!

Shabbat:  Ahad Ha’am was an early Zionist thinker, philosopher and writer.  He penned the famous line, “More than the Jews have kept the Sabbath, the Sabbath has kept the Jews.”  Jewish law has varying interpretations of how to keep the Sabbath and modern Jews find many different ways of observing it.  Whether your Shabbat practice is to shut off all electronic devices, make Kiddush and light candles on Friday night, or simply savor your favorite book; Shabbat can be a very special time for families.  Would I love to have all of you decide today to be traditionally observant of Shabbat, YES, but I think that you can gain many of the benefits of Shabbat without entirely changing your lives.  Talk to me about your Shabbat practices.  Make a special dinner.  Save a great article.  If you use TV on Shabbat, skip the violence and watch a nice movie with your loved ones.  If you use the phone, call your children--make Shabbat a time of connection.

Judaism is not a religion lived in isolation.  We are commanded to live in the world and continually improve it.  For some Jews, Tikkun Olam, Redeeming/Repairing the World, is their primary connection to Jewish life.  Whether volunteering at Habitat for Humanity, donating blood, giving tzedekah, there are many ways to help the world.  If you are looking for suggestions or have suggestions, be in touch!

Many recent books about the future of Judaism in America say that one of the most important things we can do is to build communities.  When we build community, we use our sacred values to look out for one another.  We do not want to be the synagogue where someone leaves after a decade not knowing anyone.  We want to be the place where people feel welcome from day one.  In the last two years, I think we have made tremendous strides in that direction.   Yet, welcoming and building community neither happen overnight nor are once and done programs.  They are long term, continued and committed efforts to make sure that every single member of our community feels valued and an important part of our congregational whole.  In a day and age when our families are scattered around the country, if not the globe, our congregation has an opportunity to bring people together.  We cannot neglect this responsibility.

Teaching Jewish Values:  We live this through teaching our children, through the rituals of Simchat Bat and Brit Milah, through B’nai Mitzvah, but also through daily life.  We teach Jewish Values in every interaction we have with anyone.  Every time we talk to someone; every business deal we make; every class we teach; every patient we treat is an opportunity to demonstrate and reflect our values.  Powerfully, Temple Emmanuel has created a “Living Legacy Guide” a way for you to think about your values and share them with your loved ones. I mentioned earlier that we will soon have an opportunity to think about our family trees.  Sharing our history, sharing our values is a poewrful expression.  Writing down the things that matter to us are just as important as telling our children the account numbers of our bank accounts.  Long after our physical inheritances have been saved, invested or spent, our spiritual, educational, emotional inheritances will resonate.

Over these High Holy Days, I have mentioned the Gd-shaped hole, the idea that we can feel far more fulfilled, complete, and happy if we let Gd in.  Sharing these seven gates are seven different ways for you to let Gd in.  Seven different gates, seven different days, seven different opportunities.  Looking around this room, I see people of different backgrounds, different ideas, different politics.  Why would I expect that every single person connects to Gd, each other, the same way?  The seven different gates show us that we are individuals.  All of the gates should be important to us in SOME way, but for all of us, one gate will probably speak to us more than another.  Our tradition speaks of shivim panim batorah, the seventy faces of Torah, really meaning that there are many different ways, many different access points.  On Rosh Hashanah I mentioned that even the opening of the Amidah, when we remind Gd of our connection to our ancestors, we also remind ourselves that our ancestors were individuals.  We remind ourselves that our ancestors connected to Gd in different ways.  It is a lesson that is very easy to forget.  As a rabbi, prayer is very important to me.  Yet being married to my lovely wife and now being a father to an amazing daughter, I see that my attitude towards prayer has changed.  My prayers may be briefer, but they feel more powerful.  I am more grateful, more thankful than I have ever been.

Watching all of you, looking at the example of my parents and grandparents, I see people who have connected to our traditions.  Their observance may have waxed and waned, but they always knew they were Jewish and their lives reflected that.  In just a moment, we will offer our Yizkor prayers.  We will remember those who had an influence on us.  We will remember their Jewish lives.  We will think of their yiddishe neshamas, the aspects of them that brought us joy and infused a spirit of holiness.  Whether we think of brisket and kugel, afternoons with a crossword puzzle, memories of shul, walks on the beach, mornings in a store or pushcart or an office, the ones we loved influenced us greatly.  Many of them built this shul (or the ones on Grand or Williams Streets).  We stand in their footsteps.  They spent their lives bringing our families together.  Let us spend our doing the same.  Our shul may not look exactly the same--the people in the bimah certainly look a little different--but the spirit we bring is the same.  We come together to celebrate Torah, Prayer, Israel, Shabbat, Redeeming the World, Building Community, and Teaching Jewish Values.  Together those principles have changed my life and I know they have changed all of yours.  May the coming year continue to bring us holiness, happiness and the power of community.